Review: Our Lady of Mysterious Ailments

Second books are as much make or break for a series as the first. Not only does the author have to reintroduce the characters and world from the first novel, but they also have to reveal new aspects to both. The characters must be deeper and richer. The world must be larger and more mysterious. Often, the author will have been working on book one for a long time to get it noticed by an agent and then by a publisher. Book two will usually have a shorter drafting time, but the author will also have leveled up their writing skills simply by working with publishing professionals. This is why often the second, or even third, book in a series is the best. When a first book is as high quality as The Library of the Dead, the bar is set high for the second book. In Our Lady of Mysterious Ailments, T.L. Huchu sailed over that high bar. While maintaining the same cast of characters as the first book, Huchu opens up the lens on Ropa Moyo’s world. As much as I liked The Library of the Dead, Our Lady of Mysterious Ailments is the better book and solidifies the Edinburgh Nights series as a must read for me.

Disclaimer: The publisher provided a copy of this book in exchange for an honest review. Any and all opinions that follow are mine alone.

© PrimmLife.com 2022

TL;DR

Our Lady of Mysterious Ailments solidifies T.L. Huchu as an author to follow. The Edinburgh Nights series has become a must read for me. Don’t miss this urban fantasy. Highly recommended.

Review: Our Lady of Mysterious Ailments by T.L. Huchu
Click the image to learn more at Left Bank Books

From the Publisher

Our Lady of Mysterious Ailments by T. L. Huchu is the second spellbinding book in the Edinburgh Nights series.

“Stupendously engaging.” – Ben Aaronovitch, bestselling author of Rivers of London


Some secrets are meant to stay buried

When Ropa Moyo discovered an occult underground library, she expected great things. She’s really into Edinburgh’s secret societies – but turns out they are less into her. So instead of getting paid to work magic, she’s had to accept a crummy unpaid internship. And her with bills to pay and a pet fox to feed.

Then her friend Priya offers her a job on the side. Priya works at Our Lady of Mysterious Maladies, a very specialized hospital, where a new illness is resisting magical and medical remedies alike. The first patient was a teenage boy, Max Wu, and his healers are baffled. If Ropa can solve the case, she might earn as she learns – and impress her mentor, Sir Callander.

Her sleuthing will lead her to a lost fortune, an avenging spirit and a secret buried deep in Scotland’s past. But how are they connected? Lives are at stake and Ropa is running out of time.

Review: Our Lady of Mysterious Ailments by T.L. Huchu

At the end of The Library of the Dead, Ropa has just begun to explore the larger world of Scottish magic. At the start of Our Lady of Mysterious Ailments she’s interviewing for an internship with one of the pillars of Scottish magic, the Society of Sceptical Enquirers. Her mentor, Sir Ian Callander, wants her not only to study under him but also to work for him. The interview goes okay-ish. Ropa lands the job barely, and it’s converted into an unpaid internship. Since Ropa is constantly hustling to support her family, the loss of the salary benefit is devastating. But Ropa isn’t one to dwell in her sadness. Her friend, Priyanka Kapoor, called her about a mysterious illness threatening a young man’s life. Ropa goes to Our Lady of Mysterious Ailments and finds an opportunity to make some side money as a private, supernatural investigator. This is a step up from The Library of the Dead, where Ropa mainly acted as a messenger from spirits to the living. Ropa searches for what exactly the boy was doing to contract a supernatural illness. Along the way, she stumbles into a plot to upend Scottish magic for all time.

Our Lady of Mysterious Ailments is a first person novel. It’s the second in the Edinburgh Nights series by T.L. Huchu. This urban fantasy set in an alternate Edinburgh starts off fast and doesn’t slow down. Ropa has moved out of her safe space of simply being a ghostalker and is now involved in the politics of Scottish magic. Being that she’s not got the formal education of other highbrow Scottish magicians, Ropa is an outsider. In this book, she struggles against classist reactions to her earning such a prestigious position as Sir Callander’s protege. Where The Library of the Dead was focused on Ropa and letting the reader get to know her and her abilities, Our Lady of Mysterious Ailments zooms out to let the reader experience more of the magical world surrounding Ropa. So much lore is hinted at in this book, and when I finished the last page, I began to wonder at the history hinted at in these pages. Huchu has put enough threads in this book that I want answers to.

Cast of Characters

As I said earlier, Our Lady of Mysterious Ailments expands the spotlight to allow some of the side characters to shine. Gran and Izwi added to the first book by being motivation for Ropa; here, they get fleshed out more and feel more three-dimensional to me. Gran, especially, has a larger role to play in the series overall. I imagine that we’ll get books exploring her backstory in future installments, and I’m looking forward to them. She, and her magic, seem poised between the official Scottish magic and the wild magic of the Travelers. Since her magic seems to have African roots, it won’t surprise me at all to find out her magic is both older and more in touch with the natural world than Scottish magic. But right now, Gran doesn’t want to expose Ropa to that magic. Is it because of what happened to Ropa’s parents?

Izwi gets more of a personality in this book. In the first installment, the most I remember about her is that she played games on Ropa’s phone. Well, here, we learn about her temper and how she reacts to Ropa constantly running off without her. At this point, I can’t see a role for Izwi in the larger story, but there’s definitely possibility for her to move from background to foreground character.

Sir Ian Callander is a proper Scottish man from the upper crust’s upper crust. Despite all the prejudices built into those ranks, Callander sees something in Ropa. He genuinely cares for her, but it comes across in the paternalistic way of the upper class. He provides her opportunities, instruction, and shelters her from certain office politics. But when she’s scrambling for money, she’s on her own. It’s not clear what role Callander sees for her, but he does see her potential. And he does take his role as mentor seriously. With the hints at a larger backstory between him and Ropa’s gran, Callander is man whose past readers need to know.

While the above characters provide for intrigue and questions, the heart of the novel comes from Ropa’s relationship with her friends Priyanka Kapoor and Jomo Maige. These relationships played a small role in The Library of the Dead, but they come to the foreground in a large way. I loved it when these characters got together. Their friendship felt earned, not just a plot device. I can imagine them hanging out between books. Readers see a bit more about both Priyanka and Jomo’s skills in this book. It’s a good reminder that they’re farther along in their studies than Ropa. How this trio evolves will be an interesting part of future books.

A Larger World

In addition to Calton Hill Library, in this second book readers get to see other important spots of Scottish magic, including, strangely enough, the Royal Bank of Scotland and its archives. Ropa also makes a trip to the Edinburgh Ordinary School for Boys, one of the only four accredited magical schools in all of Scotland. Ropa also takes readers to a Traveler’s camp. Each of these locations hint at a much larger world beyond Ropa’s narrow perspective.

We also get to see more magic than ghostalking and traveling to the everyThere. As Ropa begins to move in circles with more licensed magicians, readers begin to see more of how magic is used. Huchu posits some uses that I never thought of but make complete sense. For example, one of the background characters does magic as effects for movies. Ropa’s Edinburgh is a dangerous place, and magic isn’t the only thing that will protect her. But I imagine as she grows in skill, she’ll use it more and more, leaving her slingshot and dagger behind.

Conclusion

T.L. Huchu’s Our Lady of Mysterious Ailments solidified the Edinburgh Nights series as a must read urban fantasy for me. Huchu balances excellent story telling with intriguing world building. If you’re an urban fantasy fan, this series is not to be missed.

Our Lady of Mysterious Ailments by T.L. Huchu is available from Tor Books on April 5th, 2022.

© PrimmLife.com 2022

7.5 out of 10!